rubens is out and massa is in.....
Man... If you think RB has always been mediocre.. thats your opinion, but to say RB never threatened MS tells me how little you know about Ferrari politics, they would never ever have let RB threaten their golden boy. And lets just say Ferrari gave both drivers equal ground youre still talking about threatening possibly the best driver since AS. When RB was given some open reigns when MS already had his championship in the bag, you saw what RB could do..74GTVEEE said:RB was under contract for 06 and per him and JT, there was no escape unless Ferrari let him go. I didn't think RB just became a mediocre driver, but I think he was always a mediocre driver. He had the best car in the world for 5 years and never threatened MS once. Perphaps I should not judge him against the best ever...
I didn't say he was mediocre because he wasn't the top guy, I said he was mediocre because it is my opinion. I still like him. But I don't think he can ever be champion. Regardless of politics, he would never threaten MS for anything.HenryKrinkle said:Man... If you think RB has always been mediocre.. thats your opinion, but to say RB never threatened MS tells me how little you know about Ferrari politics, they would never ever have let RB threaten their golden boy. And lets just say Ferrari gave both drivers equal ground youre still talking about threatening possibly the best driver since AS. When RB was given some open reigns when MS already had his championship in the bag, you saw what RB could do..
And remember as much as RB has done in the last 5 years it was always as a #2 man. And although Im not one of these guys to call somebody mediocre just because theyre not the top guy, its good to see people like that will always exist. haha...
Actually I know enough about Ferrari politics to form my opinion. If it differs from yours then so be it.HenryKrinkle said:Man... If you think RB has always been mediocre.. thats your opinion, but to say RB never threatened MS tells me how little you know about Ferrari politics
74GTVEEE said:You implied RB was mediocre because he never threatened MS at Ferrari.HenryKrinkle said:Man... If you think RB has always been mediocre.. thats your opinion, but to say RB never threatened MS tells me how little you know about Ferrari politics, QUOTE]
Actually I know enough about Ferrari politics to form my opinion. If it differs from yours then so be it.
"I didn't think RB just became a mediocre driver, but I think he was always a mediocre driver. He had the best car in the world for 5 years and never threatened MS once. Perphaps I should not judge him against the best ever..."
Which I obviously dispelled as a ridiculous claim because RB was contractually not ABLE to threaten MS, so how could he? This doesnt have to do with your opinion vs. mine on this point, its just wrong. Unless youre still saying RB never threatened MS at Ferrari? then yes I guess we would still have different opinions about that..
But back to your opinion vs. mine on whether or not RB is a mediocre driver, last time ive checked Merriam's, hah, the word mediocre means...
: of moderate or low quality, value, ability, or performance : ordinary.
Well we know what Rubens value was to Ferrari over the last 5 seasons, count up the constructor's championships..unless youre just going to ignore his points?.. Or are you going to argue the car did it? Thats an easy out. The car that RB tested along with MS? Did RB just test the car and come back in and say "Its verrii good, just give me Micaeel's setup" haha. Or maybe Massa's?
Ordinary..
He averaged a 2.75 place in the driver's championship over the last 4 seasons of Ferrari, in an average field of 20 thats a very very high percentile in a class of near superhuman drivers in their own right. So even using calculative figures you can see Rubens is exceptional. not ordinary.
And if you still argue he is mediocre then I would have to say you cannot see the facts, you just want to stick by your opinion because its yours, or you just dont like Ruben for whatever reason. His "driving" style perhaps? hah. I mean what do you base mediocre for race car drivers? its all about winning and points, and the #s dont lie. I promise youthats one mediocre driver Id like to have on my team.
And again, you take out MS at the top, (which obviously is impossible) where would RB have been? he was 2nd in championship points as a #2 team driver (used to block other drivers, slow up the rest of the field, do the "dirty work" if you will) for a couple of those years... so you dont just call guys who arent at the top mediocre? I ask again.. Or do you just wait till theyre past their primes , teams are losing, to call them that?
Yep.HenryKrinkle said:Ordinary..
Your logic is forgetting that for MOST of the last 4 years there have ONLY been 2 competitive cars on the grid ... both Ferraris, thus any old monkey could have average 2.75 place in the driver's WC.He averaged a 2.75 place in the driver's championship over the last 4 seasons of Ferrari, in an average field of 20 thats a very very high percentile in a class of near superhuman drivers in their own right. So even using calculative figures you can see Rubens is exceptional. not ordinary.
But RB could have atleast trailed him, or beaten him in testing and MADE the team look at him ... but he just does have enough competitive spirit.... but to say RB never threatened MS tells me how little you know about Ferrari politics, they would never ever have let RB threaten their golden boy.
It seems to me like this will be the real test. Soon we will all see how he does out from under Schumacher's shadow.74GTVEEE said:RB will still be mediocre at BAR too.
Krinkle,HenryKrinkle said:PSk
"But RB could have atleast trailed him, or beaten him in testing and MADE the team look at him ... but he just does have enough competitive spirit."
First off, any driver who willing to risk an entire race, with a guaranteed podium finish, overtaking a driver on the last curve of the last lap.. Has competitive spirit, anyone who says RB lacks competitive spirit I think are somehow locked onto the moments when RB had to let MS pass him.