Alfa Romeo Forums banner

1 - 20 of 30 Posts

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
6,377 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
There seem to be several Giulia buybacks with branded titles for sale that are up to 5k less. Can anyone share thoughts on this?
 

·
Supporting Vendor
Joined
·
4,357 Posts
A lot of early Giulia buy-backs were due to electronic glitches that were ultimately traced to bad batteries. These cars are VERY sensitive to low voltage starts which will cause a huge number of error codes. Very few that I have seen or hear of have any actual hard part failures at all.

I would see if they can give you any service history as to the reason for the buyback or an extended warranty as part of the deal.

But IMHO - $5k off is not enough to bother with a car with a branded title. I think you can do just as well shopping around on new cars with clean titles.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
6,377 Posts
Discussion Starter #3
The 5k off was off the normal used price of 25-26k.
There was a 2017 for 20,995 with 2,000 miles with only three reported instances on the car fax. Mainly electrical. I was seriously considering it but it has the garish red interior with red leather seats. I'm sure it's for some but I just couldn't do it. The branded title thing also was part of it but if it had the tan interior I might already be driving it.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
547 Posts
I just signed the paperwork on a 2017 buyback. I should be picking it up tomorrow. The paperwork shows that the turbo was replaced, so I’m hoping that it was just a case of a manufacturing defect and I won’t have ongoing issues.

It’s a silver Q4 TI with the 19” sport package and pretty much all the other options except the panorama sunroof, which, living in Phoenix, I didn’t want anyway. I paid a little under $22k.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
6,377 Posts
Discussion Starter #5
If the car I got was a buyback I'd have done it. The laws in Florida and California make it very easy to return a vehicle. So much so that some buybacks are due to someone losing their job or something changed to make them not want the car. Anything can be fixed if it needs it so my biggest concern with buybacks is that in most states including Texas you get a "branded" title that stays with the car like a salvage title. Other than that, NBD. Congratulations!! If you like yours half as much as I like mine you are one happy camper! My only problem is the 74 GTV is already jealous.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
547 Posts
So after driving the car for a couple days, I can safely say that I’m very pleased with my purchase. I have to admit that I do miss the third pedal, but I think I’ll get over that. These cars are pretty amazing to drive.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
6,377 Posts
Discussion Starter #7
After all the rigmarole I went through to get my GTV to idle with the aircon on without dying the Giulia dies at idle. I guess the dealer can figure that our though. Or it would make a good Aggie joke.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
169 Posts
A lot of early Giulia buy-backs were due to electronic glitches that were ultimately traced to bad batteries. These cars are VERY sensitive to low voltage starts which will cause a huge number of error codes. Very few that I have seen or hear of have any actual hard part failures at all.

I would see if they can give you any service history as to the reason for the buyback or an extended warranty as part of the deal.

But IMHO - $5k off is not enough to bother with a car with a branded title. I think you can do just as well shopping around on new cars with clean titles.

Joe, don't know if you've seen the latest issue of C&D but it totally trashed the QV (or QF as some call it) in its 40k mile test due completely to electronic glitches. The car never stranded them or didn't start or had to be towed but no one could find any fixes for the glitches because they came and went sometimes multiple times. They are now telling everyone not buy or even lease a Quad because of their horrible experience. No one including the Alfa techs even mentioned let alone checked the battery. But it seems you have knowledge about these problems and their fixes with new batteries. So what's going on with Alfa that they didn't have this information for C&D? Have you had any of these problems with your car and if so what fixes were necessary.

This is the kind of crap Alfa can't afford to happen in front of the whole world and not have a clue as to how to fix these glitches besides throwing new parts on the car and still have the same problems. I'm pretty pissed at Alfa right now because they're screwing this thing up for the rest of us who have great reliable cars; and it's this kind of stuff that can ****can the whole thing, for good.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
923 Posts
Joe, don't know if you've seen the latest issue of C&D but it totally trashed the QV (or QF as some call it) in its 40k mile test due completely to electronic glitches. The car never stranded them or didn't start or had to be towed but no one could find any fixes for the glitches because they came and went sometimes multiple times. They are now telling everyone not buy or even lease a Quad because of their horrible experience. ....

This is the kind of crap Alfa can't afford to happen in front of the whole world and not have a clue as to how to fix these glitches besides throwing new parts on the car and still have the same problems. I'm pretty pissed at Alfa right now because they're screwing this thing up for the rest of us who have great reliable cars; and it's this kind of stuff that can ****can the whole thing, for good.
Trust me, over on the Cadillac ATS forum and ATS Facebook groups, they are quoting that **** C&D article, and patting themselves on the back for their Caddy ATS/ATS-V purchases, never mind that the Caddies have had their niggling issues, and a BIG one is the GM Auto 8sp tranny - a class action lawsuit in progress. Granted, the issues with the tranny are smoothness/optimal performance related, not catastrophic. Still I take some offense to the 'gang mentality' where they all site the usual Italian car maintenance/reliability sad stories... not wanting to realize its just a small portion of production, and related to s/w... NOT hardware/design flaw.

In the meantime, Caddy ATS owners wallow in the same severe depreciation for their cars (due to poor Caddy/GM reputation) as Alfa Giulia owners. So I find it so disingenuous that these compromised Caddy owners are so willing to throw stones from their glass houses.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
6,377 Posts
Discussion Starter #10
I'm a little confused. Is it the QV or the Quad they are talking about? Regardless they need to get their act together. At 23k my QV has been flawless. Going from a GTV daily driver to a Giulia there have been some issues but all can be traced to a loose nut behind the wheel. No doubt about it Alfa nailed it with the Giulia. It should be the car of the decade.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,783 Posts
Friend of mine wholesaled his Ferrari FF because of repeated electrical faults. Ferrari North America would not authorize battery replacement for quite some time before the mechanic just decided to do it. Fixed all the issues but that was far too late for this new Ferrari customer. Bad tastes last a long time.

One tidbit about modern engines with stop/start systems: these are programmed to stop operating when battery voltage drops below a certain point. Since the software continuously monitors the main service battery during periods of engine stop battery faults can be detected very easily and early. The alternator also stops of course allowing for very accurate battery drain rate inputs into the stop start software. First thing to check if the stop start system doesn't operate reliably is the main service battery.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
6,377 Posts
Discussion Starter #12
The impression I got from reading the owners manual, if you can believe that I actually read most of it, was battery voltage was a big deal since it was mentioned so many times in relation to things working or not working.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
169 Posts
I'm a little confused. Is it the QV or the Quad they are talking about? Regardless they need to get their act together. At 23k my QV has been flawless. Going from a GTV daily driver to a Giulia there have been some issues but all can be traced to a loose nut behind the wheel. No doubt about it Alfa nailed it with the Giulia. It should be the car of the decade.

It's the Quad that C&D is talking about not the Giulia Ti, which by the way was named the best sport sedan on the market and the new Ultimate Driving Machine by Motortrend magazine.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
169 Posts
The impression I got from reading the owners manual, if you can believe that I actually read most of it, was battery voltage was a big deal since it was mentioned so many times in relation to things working or not working.
EXACTLY! so why in the hell didn't Alfa know this. Bulls*@t that's all it is.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
169 Posts
The hell with the Caddy owners Renaldo I'm just really pissed at Alfa for letting all this crap transpire in the first place, especially since there is apparently an easy fix that could have resolved all the problems.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
21 Posts
The model has changed: Nagging software and technical problems aren't solved anywhere but where they were originally designed, layer upon layer above the consumers return for warranty service.

. . .So the question is: does FCA has the management culture in place to attack these quality issues and beat these Lemon laws in a race for Alfa's reputation? …. I'm not weighing in, my wife told me to stop being so negative. :[
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
342 Posts
I have a Stelvio Ti was a 2018 demo I purchased with 6,000 miles not a buyback. It had any of the Stelvio updates to current. I have driven it 11,000 miles in the last four months, no issues and super happy. While I would have preferred a sedan I needed the room.

While the Quad halo cars need to be better, Alfa’s growth rides more on Stelvio success and I hope my current experience predicts the future. I am seeing more on the road and get unsolicited comments regularly to the good.

My car does not have Apple car play or Android auto and cannot be retrofitted easily without sourcing a lot of parts from a donor car and updating software! Doesn’t bother me too much but should have been offered from the start. My daughters mid level cx5 has better features. Am sure that is one of the reasons I had a great price on the otherwise spotless demo car. Oh, no shift paddles/sunroof/sport seats/premium stereo but yes on metallic paint, 19” wheels, advanced safety features, aluminum interior trim. It’s perfect for my weekly NJ to MA commute. A blast to drive. Quad would have been nice but a waste for my commuting.

If needed I can make it into a Stelvio Ti Super by doing an ECU flash, exhaust, 18x9 wheels from Alfa9, and sport seats from a wrecked car. Shift paddles a bit harder though.

If I want more fun, I have 2 GTV6s and will wait for the new GTV, or buy a used Guilia Quad or 4C.

Hope FCA gets this sorted out, these cars are fundamentally great but in super competitive spaces.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
446 Posts
I'm a little lost on what's going on perhaps you can fill me in.

I went to the dealer last weekend and didn't like the 2019 but was really hot to purchase a Giulia when I initially saw them in 2017. The real driver for me was that I thought the car had a V6... The new model I saw just has a funky SOHC engine and is AWD, and the dealer said that it would be a special order to get a rear wheel drive car. he has two 2018's on the lot, should I avoid at all costs?


So did these cars EVER have a V6 or was that just initial hype. Maybe its not the Giulia that I should be asking for... There's no way I could spring for a 4C... My 92 spyder has a DOHC that only puts out 105Hp from its 2 liter but it sounds so fine maybe I should just sink 5K into it to get new paint, interior and door dings removed.... where's phantom works when you need them? I would like to know what I should ask it I were to post it for sale?

Tks Franco in springfield, va.
 

Attachments

·
Registered
Joined
·
169 Posts
The Giulia Quadrifoglio has a V6, the Giulia and Giulia Ti are 4 bangers and that includes the Q2 (rear drive) and the Q4 (all wheel drive).
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
446 Posts
I'm having second thoughts on this potential purchase. What's the dealer not telling me. Can someone explain the Buy Back situation? I love my 92 spyder. The dealer said he would take in in trade, but I have no idea what a fair price would be. I'm the second owner, (purchased in 94) the car has been well maintained, there's a new top that hasn't seen a day of rain since its a garage queen. I would post it in the For Sale section along with plenty of pictures. There's the door dings, and worn upholstery don't really bother me because its light and nimble even if its not blistering off the line.

I need more information, like price differences between Quadrifolio and various 4 banger, then there's the confusion over options like sports package, mediterranian etc. but the real question is why the buy back program?

thanks
Franco in Springfield Va
 
1 - 20 of 30 Posts
Top