What does the owner's manual recommend from new? How is the oil pressure compared to when newer?
I would stay with the recommended weight unless you have a real problem with actual low oil pressure, checked with mechanical gauge.
I might offer an example, I have 189k miles on my 91S (admittedly a different engine), and the V6 oil pressure is still the same (25/30 psi idle hot and 50/55 psi at 3000rpm cruise) as when I bought it used with 40k miles on it, still using the usual 15W/20W-50 oil, with the recommended higher levels of zinc/phosphorus, as used from the date of the purchase, 1994.
The point is, while I admit the weight of these oils most of us use in the 164 are a little higher than what the manual recommends (because of being the very few oils available these days with the higher levels of desired flat tappet antiwear additives) the pressure has not changed/dropped with the high mileage.
So, unless indicated by measured evidence, I wouldn't expect that you would need to change from the owner's manual values.
If the engine has oil leaks from worn seals, you might try the "High Mileage" version of the recommended oil, as those oils are supposed to slightly swell the rubber seals a little to sort of renew their fit, at least potentially slowing leaks.
Disclaimer: of course, others may have a different opinion, based on their own experience.
1 - 2 of 2 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.