View Single Post
  #173 (permalink)  
Old 05-31-2008, 10:39 AM
rogerspeed's Avatar
rogerspeed rogerspeed is online now
Senior Member
Gold Subscriber
 
Join Date: May 2005
Location: OC CA USA
Posts: 1,612
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pat Braden View Post
Jerry,

You must have gotten your car back since we haven't had any new cartoons lately. Someone must have forgotten the bribe payment to the mechanic.

You will be happy to know that your work is protected in California, I don't know about the other 49 states. I tried several places today to try and have image #12 put on a shirt to wear to the convention, the answer I got everywhere from low-priced to high-priced was not without a copyright release from the creator. It was obvious to anyone wherever I tried that it was intellectual property and therefore fell under copyright laws.

Yes, I was honest when they asked me how I got the picture and explained the situation; these are the same people that printed Patty's picture of Pat on my shirt last year; the difference, she was my daughter; and even though this was posted to the Internet, it is still protected by copyright to the creator. I'm not surprised, somewhat disappointed, but didn't expect them to pick up on it or request what they did to be able to use it.

So for all of you that scoffed at the two CarDisc threads about copyright and have commented on Pat's work being copyrighted that has appeared in The Owner under a one-time use provision, both of those show registered copyright marks; here's one without a printed copyright, but assumed to be copyrighted and protected under intellectual property and copyright provisions.

A lesson to us all....about it's importance and that some companies do care about abiding by the law; not at all meant to intimate that I was trying to break it. Jerry, knew I was going to have a shirt made for the convention.
Pat, Fom experience and from the evidence you have presented, I come to a different conclusion; companies are risk adverse and wish to avoid any possibility of litagation. You may remember the cartonist R.Crumb who created the famous "keep on trucking" cartoon, he didn't apply for a copyright and when he sued others for using the image and slogan he created, he lost. I strongly advise Jerry to copyright his work. Now laws may have changed and artist rights have been strengthened but personal use of non-copyrighted images (even copyrighted) not for financial gain/profit should be protected by the first admendment (fair use/free speech), but most businesses aren't worried about the rights of citizens, they are worried about the costs of litigation.

PS - can't resist, in addition to driving a Cosmo, Kramer watches Versus
__________________
'67 BMW 1600ti/Alpina
And Looking For Another
www.resoles.com
"just say no to reductionism"

Last edited by rogerspeed; 05-31-2008 at 11:05 AM.
Reply With Quote